Does trading beat just holding?

We ran the backtests to find out. We test buy-the-dip and other timing rules on stocks and ETFs, through crashes and bull runs, and count how often they beat buying and holding. Mostly they don't, and we say so. Every ticker starts with a one-line answer, and the full method is there when you want it.

Across the 38 published tickers, a median 6.8% of backtests beat buy-and-hold, while a median 81.6% of closed trades made money in default-settings backtests. Both figures are shown for every ticker.

AAPL, Apple Inc.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 78% of closed trades made money.

AMD, Advanced Micro Devices: 10.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 69.9% of closed trades made money.

AMZN, Amazon.com Inc.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 82.2% of closed trades made money.

ARKK, ARK Innovation ETF: 25% of 553 backtests beat holding; 81.7% of closed trades made money.

BA, Boeing Co.: 3.1% of 553 backtests beat holding; 79.4% of closed trades made money.

COIN, Coinbase Global: 95.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 70.9% of closed trades made money.

CRWD, CrowdStrike Holdings: 7.6% of 553 backtests beat holding; 82.6% of closed trades made money.

DDOG, Datadog Inc.: 9.8% of 553 backtests beat holding; 74.8% of closed trades made money.

DIS, Walt Disney Co.: 12.8% of 553 backtests beat holding; 79.5% of closed trades made money.

GLD, SPDR Gold Shares: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 75.9% of closed trades made money.

GOOGL, Alphabet Inc.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 82.4% of closed trades made money.

GS, Goldman Sachs: 10.3% of 553 backtests beat holding; 77.1% of closed trades made money.

IWM, iShares Russell 2000: 6% of 553 backtests beat holding; 80.7% of closed trades made money.

JPM, JPMorgan Chase: 16.3% of 553 backtests beat holding; 80.6% of closed trades made money.

MA, Mastercard Inc.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 88.8% of closed trades made money.

META, Meta Platforms: 24.4% of 553 backtests beat holding; 84% of closed trades made money.

MSFT, Microsoft Corp.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 81.4% of closed trades made money.

NBIS, Nebius Group: 23.3% of 553 backtests beat holding; 88.9% of closed trades made money.

NET, Cloudflare Inc.: 21.9% of 553 backtests beat holding; 82.1% of closed trades made money.

NFLX, Netflix Inc.: 28.2% of 553 backtests beat holding; 82% of closed trades made money.

NVDA, NVIDIA Corp.: 0.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 82% of closed trades made money.

PLTR, Palantir Technologies: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 79.6% of closed trades made money.

PYPL, PayPal Holdings: 47.6% of 553 backtests beat holding; 81% of closed trades made money.

QQQ, Invesco QQQ Trust: 17.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 83.6% of closed trades made money.

SHOP, Shopify Inc.: 5.8% of 553 backtests beat holding; 88.9% of closed trades made money.

SNOW, Snowflake Inc.: 13.9% of 553 backtests beat holding; 69.5% of closed trades made money.

SPY, SPDR S&P 500 ETF: 0.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 87.8% of closed trades made money.

TLT, iShares 20+ Year Treasury: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 73.4% of closed trades made money.

TQQQ, ProShares UltraPro QQQ: 6% of 553 backtests beat holding; 83.1% of closed trades made money.

TSLA, Tesla Inc.: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 70.8% of closed trades made money.

V, Visa Inc.: 4% of 553 backtests beat holding; 86.7% of closed trades made money.

VOO, Vanguard S&P 500: None of 553 backtests beat holding; 87.1% of closed trades made money.

VTI, Vanguard Total Stock Market: 1.1% of 553 backtests beat holding; 87.5% of closed trades made money.

XBI, SPDR S&P Biotech: 12.3% of 553 backtests beat holding; 75.7% of closed trades made money.

XLE, Energy Select SPDR: 5.8% of 553 backtests beat holding; 80.3% of closed trades made money.

XLK, Technology Select SPDR: 17.5% of 553 backtests beat holding; 84.9% of closed trades made money.

XLV, Health Care Select SPDR: 11.8% of 553 backtests beat holding; 82.6% of closed trades made money.

ZS, Zscaler Inc.: 25% of 553 backtests beat holding; 74.8% of closed trades made money.

Start broad. Narrow only when it helps.

Simple: Is this strategy worth looking at?

Explore: Regime breakdowns and risk metrics

Method: How the evidence was produced

Can market research be useful without being overconfident?

Every verdict shows the evidence first, splits the results into crash and bull markets, and keeps the caveats next to the numbers. You can check how each one was made.

Compare any two tickers

Put two tickers side by side: their pentagon scores, win rates, how often each beat buy-and-hold, and which has the stronger evidence. Open the comparison tool